Comments

18.05.2015 20:28

LoriAnn Otano

Have a B.S. (Honors) in Physical Education and Health science taking MORE science classes than a BSN! Have Associates (Honors) in Nursing for 27 yrs. No hospital will hire me, total BS!!!!

18.05.2015 17:29

Mary

I so so totally agree!!!!! I have been a nurse for 21 yrs. I went through a assoc. Of science -nursing program. One of the best in the state and I by far feel I am better trained then a BSN.

18.05.2015 16:31

Mike

It's not just magnet hospitals that suffer from this sort of silliness toward nurses. Nurses are micromanaged and disrespected, increasingly, all across the spectrum. Don't go into nursing.

18.05.2015 15:57

Sandy Boguszewski

Oh so true ! That is why I retired after forty -
one years of bedside nursing.

18.05.2015 15:30

Angela Herman

That was great. I worked for a 4 time Magnet hospital left one year ago after 15 YEARS. More work on your own time and no more pay.

18.05.2015 14:28

Zondra Myers

WOW! You hit it. The only omission is real time charting that takes away from actual patient care. Good job!

18.05.2015 13:30

Karen Lamberton

A lot of 'truth-telling' in this essay!! Time compression and burnout are sky-rocketing. Seasoned nurses are opting out. Commitee membership is being tied to 'stewardship ' and performance appraisal.

18.05.2015 06:03

Phyllis Margaret

I agree with some of the statements in this article but not all. There are many BSN nurses who stay in direct nursing care. For that matter there are MSN nurses who are clinical specialists in direct

18.05.2015 04:37

JD

Magnet is a journey STRAIGHT TO HELL!!
I have been doing this for more than 30 yrs& there is not a pill or a program or an app that can replace an human empathy& experience of a nurse!

18.05.2015 03:44

CNA FOR 30 YRS.

As an CNA I see them making Nurses going back to school,to get BSN,and seeing them hiring Non Ceritifed Aides that don't know what to do with patients Exspecially in personal care.

18.05.2015 03:26

Denise Wyant RN

Amen

18.05.2015 02:01

Judy bentley

This is so true. YOU NO LONGER GIVE QUALITY PT. care, busy doing paper work, computer work. Most care is given by the pct's. Being a nurse you hate when your family member and friends are sick .

18.05.2015 00:15

Lois Murray

I have retired from nursing but over my 32 years on the job I have watched nurses being taken farther and farther from the bedside. Nursing was no longer what I entered nursing for.

17.05.2015 23:11

Traci Roush

And they take good nurses who are LPN'S out of the hospital because of their title. Some are still are LPN'S because of circumstances. Doesn't mean they are not good nurses.

17.05.2015 21:21

joy

Amazingly you have put into words the reality of our chosen profession. It is very sad, I have been feeling these pressure for awhile now.What can we do,who can help us?

17.05.2015 20:26

Lynn

I too am a nurse, an LPN. I passed state boards and took care of patients for 25 years. Hospitals no longer employ LPN's. I have chosen not to renew my lisense.

26.05.2015 01:29

Judith Brown

Lynn
I am an LPN for 33 yrs. Magnet has not added to my job satisfaction at all! It is all just prestige for administration who have no idea what we do!!

17.05.2015 22:49

Peggy Edel

Sorry Lynn i appreciate nurses and there is a shortage of nurses. Please renew your license, you worked too.hard to get it.

17.05.2015 20:15

Lynn

I love being a nurse, making a difference and extending compassion to the suffering ( patients and nurses).

17.05.2015 19:06

Melinda

Sounds exactly like UAB.(University of Alabama @Birmingham). Babies training babies and baby leaders. Dangerous.

17.05.2015 18:31

Melinda

True Story

17.05.2015 18:31

Nancy beller

Press Ganey is ridiculous. I actually had one of my happyest patients tell me he just throws those surveys away. Happy customers dont take the time to do surveys. Some people are always peeved .

17.05.2015 17:07

Susan Richie

AMEN!!!!!

17.05.2015 16:53

Jan

I quit ANA because of so many of the items talked about in this article. They have forgotten to focus on the nurse and how we can best help our patients. Government is ruining health care & schools.

17.05.2015 16:29

jen

Let's not forget the hideous amount of money that each hospital pays to apply and maintain the "magnet" status.

19.05.2015 17:46

Julie

You mentioned schools. Many of these reasons listed are exactly why I left teaching. I considered a 2nd prof in nursing but I'm finding much of the same gov intervention ruining yet another profession

18.05.2015 13:33

sandramccormick@twc.com

Agree Jan. I also quit ANA. They are way too political, left leaning

18.05.2015 12:41

Karen

And that there Jen is what it's all about.

17.05.2015 15:59

MB

This is the editorial I have been writing (in my mind) for years

17.05.2015 15:54

adele berry

Great commentary! You hit it "head on"!

17.05.2015 15:53

Maria

I am a Diploma nurse with 28 yrs behind me and can't change my job without committing to get my BSN within 5 yrs of hire. Why would I want my BSN when it is completely unecessary. Amen to your Blog!

17.05.2015 15:45

Alicia

I have been a nurse for 40 years and I am doing a count down on my phone till I can retire. I am a diploma school graduate and an proud of it.

17.05.2015 16:54

Jan

diploma nurses are great!

17.05.2015 15:42

Stella

I read this article with interest. But am a bit puzzled. While reading it, I found myself shaking my head and thinking, "Yep, they got that right." The thing that makes the article stand out for me,is

17.05.2015 15:16

DS

I agree with a lot of what this post says. I am a travel nurse at a Magnet hospital right now and it seems that "Magnet" = more work disguised as empowerment.

17.05.2015 15:10

Kim

Wow! This article just validated my feelings completely. The hospital is a big business run by business people not true nurses!

17.05.2015 15:08

Laura

You said it!!

17.05.2015 14:27

Kristi

Completely unsubstantiated opinions without any facts backing up your statements. I happen to work at a magnet hospital and I found this completely missed the mark.

17.05.2015 18:28

Mary

Still drinking the kool aid i see

17.05.2015 14:09

betheny pierce

Decent article & right on regarding Magnet status & cause of hiring BS degree only. Dead wrong about P&P & why Obama care in title? No correlation to this article what soever!

17.05.2015 13:40

czarina

No where in the article do I see Obamacare as the culprit. so why is the headline misleading? Why did it not state how insurance companies rule hospitals and doctors/nurses?

18.05.2015 11:35

Kathy

Totally agree! Am tired of explaining to patients why we can't give them the care they deserve!

17.05.2015 13:31

Carol

This article really states so many truths, that I found myself agreeing with out loud.

17.05.2015 12:02

lea

Wow. I am printing this out to pin on our board at work!

17.05.2015 08:51

Nita

This is one of the finest depictions of "modern" nursing I have ever read. Every single word of it is true! Thank you for spelling out my job so eloquently, albeit painfully!

17.05.2015 07:00

Dean Wagner CRNA

Your editorial provides nothing to support the obligatory right-wing bashing of Obamacare thrown out in the headline. Shame! Repetition does not equal truth!

17.05.2015 18:31

Mary

Dean, are you at a Magnet hospital? how long has it been since you practiced as a floor nurse?

17.05.2015 05:53

dreina

Amen, amen, amen.

17.05.2015 05:24

kelley

Awesome and so true...Im an RN diploma trained 30 years and this article is dead on...I have worked on a level 1 trauma center as a PICU nurse. I hate what Magnet has done to our hospital.

17.05.2015 04:02

Skip

So glad I am now a retired RN. Loved my job when it was about patient care - but not when all the changes came. If we could only go back... Not going to happen ever!

17.05.2015 02:45

Bennie Parker

I am a NICU nurse with 33 years of experience and now all I Want is to get out. You hit it right on when you say look good on paper, it really doesn't have that much to do with the patient.

17.05.2015 00:06

Ann Lak

The planets need to be in alignment. Magnet is an awesome goal for many reasons. But it needs to evolve rather than be forced. Nurse retention is an essential part with nurses controlling practice.

16.05.2015 23:55

R.E.C

You spend a lot of time criticizing all these efforts but not talking about what should be done instead. If Magnet, Press-Ganey, and so on are so bad, then what do you think is the answer?

16.05.2015 23:02

Jonathan

Why are you throwing the Affordable Care Act under the bus? You speak of the "looming threat of Obamacare", and then nothing more to explain or support your knee jerk opposition to this legislation.

16.05.2015 23:56

Jonathan

Sorry, that's not part of the ACA.

16.05.2015 23:49

cindy

Because obamacare is using the "survey" resukts to base their reimbursement. Lets focus on gicing good care and respwcting each other as professionals rather than all this "hoop-jumping".

16.05.2015 22:59

JBWard

Hospitals pay way to much to be Magnet. The money should go into nursing wages. I don't see retention. I see more turnover because down the street the hospital not Magnet is paying $6 more an hour.

16.05.2015 22:06

P.west

Being a magnet hospital just makes all nurses think they can do no wrong because of them they were able to get this recognition for there hospital when really it was a joint effort on everyone's part

16.05.2015 21:51

Michele Cummings

Been saying this for years! It is all a ruse! So glad I retired early!

16.05.2015 21:31

Beth

So true-So glad I retired early after almost 40 years-was a diploma school graduate

16.05.2015 21:27

Fonzella

I am happy to be one of the one's that took up the profession, because I loved and wanted to help people. I was not an RN, but tried, had a lot of training, my first hospital trained all of their LP